The film’s most interesting, yet botched, element is its treatment of Josh. In the game, Josh is the human villain—a grieving brother who orchestrates a cruel prank as therapy. His arc culminates in a choice: the player can forgive him (leading to his human death) or condemn him (leading to his wendigo transformation). The game’s post-credits scene reveals the latter as the “true” horror: not death, but eternal, monstrous consciousness.
Why make this film in 2024? The answer lies in the economics of “revival horror.” Following the success of The Last of Us (HBO, 2023) and Five Nights at Freddy’s (2023), studios have recognized that video game IP carries a pre-sold, nostalgic audience. However, Until Dawn differs from those properties: The Last of Us is a linear narrative game; Five Nights at Freddy’s is a jump-scare simulator. Until Dawn is a branching narrative —its identity is its non-linearity. Until Dawn -2024-
The 2024 film makes Josh the final boy, redeeming him and killing the wendigo outright. This is a catastrophic misreading. Josh is not a slasher villain; he is a tragedy of failed agency. His prank fails because he cannot control his friends any more than the player can control the dice. By redeeming him, the film eliminates the game’s most profound thematic statement: that horror is the inability to undo harm. The film’s most interesting, yet botched, element is