Critics were puzzled, and radio programmers were slow to catch on. But looking back a decade later, 4 is not a stumble. It is the album where Beyoncé shattered the pop formula and laid the foundation for the surprise-dropped, visual-album revolutionary she would become. The most striking thing about 4 is its sonic texture. In an era dominated by EDM (David Guetta, Calvin Harris) and Auto-Tune, Beyoncé went raw. She retreated to the grit of 1970s soul, 1980s funk, and 1990s R&B.
In the summer of 2011, Beyoncé Knowles-Carter was already a global icon. She had conquered the world with Destiny’s Child, dominated pop radio with Dangerously in Love , and delivered a futuristic blockbuster with B’Day . By all logical metrics, 4 —her aptly titled fourth album—should have been a victory lap. album beyonce 4
She worked with legends like Earth, Wind & Fire, sampled The Originals’ “The Bells,” and brought in producers like Kanye West and The-Dream. But the real magic came from her vocal performance. On 4 , Beyoncé stopped trying to prove she had the biggest voice and started showing she had the smartest one. Critics were puzzled, and radio programmers were slow